Appendix A: Index of Comments


Inventory Number1

Public Inquiry Number2
Source3

Medium4


Supportive of Report?5
Additional References Cited6
Individual Organization Y or N List
27 2 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
28 3 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
29 4 MCS -- E-mail 3 Y R68, R118
30 5 X -- E-mail N/A N --
31 6 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
32 7 MCS -- E-mail 2 N --
33 8 HCP -- E-mail 3 N --
34 9 HCP -- E-mail 4 N --
35 10 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
36 11 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
37 12 X -- Written 2 N --
11 13 -- National Center for Environmental Health Strategies Written 1 N --
19 14 X -- Written 2 Y R10, R14, R37, R59, R67
23 15 X -- Written 3 N --
38 16 MCS -- Written N/A Y R27, R28, R29, R11
39 17 X -- Written 2 N --
40 18 MCS -- Written 2 N --
41 19 -- Boston Self Help Center Written 2 N --
42 20 -- Boston Self Help Center Written 2 N --
43 21 MCS -- Written 3 N --
44 22 MCS -- Written 3 N --
45 23 X -- Written 3 Y R14
3 24 -- MCS Referral and Resources Written 2 Y R3, R43, R210, R211, R212, R213, R214, R215, R216, R217, R218, R219, R220, R221, R222
6 25 MCS -- E-mail 3 Y R241
47 26 MCS -- E-mail 2 Y R241
48 27 X -- E-mail 3 N --
49 28 MCS -- E-mail 4 N --
50 29 X -- E-mail 2 N --
20 30 -- Environmental Sensitivities Research Group E-mail 3 Y R97, R108, R114
51 31 MCS -- Written 3 Y R21, R23, R41, R47, R75, R76, R82, R154, R191, R192, R193, R194, R195, R196, R197, R198
52 32 X -- Written 3 N --
53 33 X -- Written 2 N --
54 34 X -- Written 2 Y R137, R141, R153
9 36 MCS -- Written 2 N --

55

37

MCS -- Written N/A N --
16 38 X -- Written 2 N --
9 39 MCS -- Written 2 N --
56 40 HCP -- Written 3 Y R236, R237
57 54 HCP -- Written 2 Y R54
58 55 HCP -- Written 4 N --
59 56 -- NIEHS Written 4 N --
61 58 HCP -- Written 3 N --
4 59 HCP -- Written N/A N --
62 60 -- ACCEH Written N/A N --
63 61 MCS -- Written N/A N --
64 62 MCS -- Written 2 N --
65 63 HCP -- Written 2 Y R3, R14, R17, R27, R33, R38, R44, R71, R72, R83, R93, R98, R99, R105, R110, R111, R157

66

64 -- APHA Written 3 Y R95

67

65 MCS -- Written N/A Y R161, R162
68 66 X -- Written 2 N --
69 67 X -- Written 2 Y R135, R136, R137
16 68 X -- Written 2 N --
70 69 MCS -- Written 2 Y R163, R164
71 70 MCS -- Written 2 Y R50, R51, R53
15 71 MCS -- Written 2 Y R43, R134
72 72 MCS -- Written 2 N --
73 73 X -- Written 2 N --
74 74 MCS -- Written 2 N --
75 75 MCS -- Written 3 N --
76 76 MCS -- Written 3 N --
8 77 MCS -- Written 3 Y R73
77 78 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
78 79 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
79 80 X -- Written 2 N --
80 81 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
81 82 -- Novartis Written 3 Y R30, R31, R32, R34, R52, R58, R60, R62, R66, R90, R92
82 83 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
83 84 X -- Written 2 Y R22, R121, R122, R162, R169
84 85 -- Environmental Health Association Written 3 N --
85 86 MCS -- Written N/A N --
86 87

--
Ohio Network for the Chemically Injured Written 3 Y R20
87 88 MCS -- Written 3 Y R72
2 89 MCS -- Written N/A N --
88 90 MCS -- Written N/A N --
89 91 MCS -- Written 3 Y R77, R127, R230
90 92 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
91 93 MCS -- Written N/A N --
92 94 X -- Written N/A N --
25 96 X -- Written 2 Y R4, R8, R45, R77, R80, R86, R127, R241
94 97 X -- Written 2 N --
95 98 X -- Written 2 N --
96 99 MCS -- Written 2 Y R176
97 100 X -- Written 2 Y R85
98 101 X -- Written 2 N --
99 102 X -- Written 2 Y R176
100 103 MCS -- Written N/A N --
101 104 MCS -- E-mail 4 N --
102 105 X -- Written 2 N --
103 106 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
22 107 MCS -- Written N/A N --
104 108 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
105 109 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
106 110 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122
107 111 MCS -- Written N/A N --
108 112 X -- E-mail N/A N --
109 113 X -- Written 1 N --
110 114 MCS -- Written N/A N --
111 115 MCS -- Written N/A N --
112 116 X -- Written 2 N --
113 117 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
10 118 MCS -- Written N/A Y R77, R126, R127
114 119 X -- Written 2 Y R233, R234, R235
115 120 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
8 121 MCS -- Written 3 Y R94, R131, R132, R88, R133
116 122 X -- Written 2 Y R134, R135, R136, R155
117 123 MCS -- Written 1 N --
118 124 -- N.C. Chemical Injury Network Written 2 N --
46 125 -- MCS/CI Support Group E-mail 3 Y R176
119 126 X -- Written 2 N --
120 127 MCS -- Written 3 N --
121 128 X -- Written 2 N --
122 129 X -- Written 2 N --
123 130 X -- Written 2 N --
124 131 X -- Written 2 N --
125 132 X -- Written 2 N --
126 133 X -- Written 2 N --
127 134 X -- Written 2 N --
128 135 X -- Written 2 N --
129 136 X -- Written 2 Y R176
130 137 MCS -- Written 2 N --
131 138 X -- Written 2 N --
5 139 -- NTEU E-mail 3 Y R6, R26
19 142 -- Chemical Sensitivity Disorders Association Written 2 Y R3, R5, R25, R36, R43, R46, R64, R103, R107, R116, R241
24 143 MCS -- Written 3 N --
7 144 X -- E-mail 2 N --
132 145 -- Satasota-manatee Task Force on the Health Effects of Pesticides Written 2 Y R24, R65, R172, R173, R175
133 146 MCS -- Written 2 N --
134 147 -- MCS: Health and Environment Written 3 Y R10, R134, R148, R158, R241
26 148 -- Ecological Health Organization E-mail 2 Y R12, R15, R40, R42, R43, R48, R64, R79, R99, R121, R122, R161, R183,
135 149 MCS -- Written 3 N --
136 150 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
137 151 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
138 152 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
139 153 MCS -- Written 3 Y R137, R165, R166, R167
140 154 MCS -- Written 3 N --
141 155 MCS -- Written N/A N --
142 156 -- Center for Occupational and Environmental Medicine Written 3 Y R167, R168, R196, R201, R202, R203, R204, R205, R206, R207, R224
143 157 X -- Written 2 N --
144 158 MCS -- Written 2 N --
145 159 X -- Written 2 Y R176
146 160 MCS -- Written 3 N --
147 161 -- Environmental Illness Assoc. of Tallahassee Written 3 Y R136, R199
148 162 MCS -- Written 2 Y R3, R25, R36, R42, R43, R46, R56, R64, R107, R116, R121, R122
149 163 X -- E-mail 2 N --
150 164 X -- Written 2 Y R241
151 165 MCS -- Written 2 N --
152 166 X -- Written 2 N --
153 167 X -- Written 2 N --
154 168 X -- Written 2 N --
155 169 MCS -- Written 2 Y R69, R84, R89, R104, R109, R119
156 170 -- Health Council of Marin Written 2 N --
157 171 -- Health and Habitat Written 2 N --
158 172 X -- Written 2 Y R176
159 173 HCP -- Written 2 Y R19, R40, R43
26 174 -- Ecological Health Organization Written 2 Y R12, R15, R40, R42, R43, R48, R64, R79, R99, R121, R122, R161, R183, R241
160 175 MCS -- Written 1 N --
161 176 X -- Written 2 N --
162 177 X -- Written 2 N --
10 178 MCS -- Written N/A N --
163 179 X -- Written 2 N --
164 180 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
165 181 MCS -- Written 2 N --
166 182 MCS -- Written 2 N --
167 183 MCS -- Written N/A N --
168 184 MCS -- Written 2 N --
169 185 X -- Written 2 N --
170 186 -- WASTE Written 2 Y R176
171 187 X -- Written 2 Y R102
172 188 MCS -- Written 3 N --
173 189 X -- Written 2 N --
174 190 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
175 191 X -- Written 2 N --
176 192 MCS -- Written 2 N --
177 193 X -- Written 2 N --
178 194 X -- Written 2 N --
180 196 MCS -- Written 2 N --
181 197 MCS -- Written 2 N --
23 198 X -- Written 2 N --
182 199 HCP -- Written 3 Y R182
183 200 MCS -- Written N/A N --
24 201 X -- Written 3 N --
7 202 MCS -- Written 4 N --
184 203 X -- Written 3 N --
185 204 MCS -- Written 2 N --
186 205 MCS -- Written 3 N --
187 206 MCS -- Written N/A Y R70
188 207 HCP -- Written 3 Y R56, R79
5 208 -- NTEU Chapter 280 Written 3 Y R6, R26
189 209 MCS -- Written 2 Y R134, R136, R137, R153, R154, R155, R156
190 210 MCS -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
191 211 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
192 212 MCS -- Written 2 N --
193 213 X -- Written 3 Y R150, R151
194 214 X -- Written 2 N --
195 215 X -- Written 3 Y R157
196 216 MCS -- Written 2 N --
197 217 MCS -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
198 218 MCS -- Written N/A N --
199 219 MCS -- E-mail 1 N --
200 220 X -- Written N/A N --
201 221 X -- Written 2 N --
202 222 X -- Written 2 N --
203 223 X -- Written 2 N --
204 224 X -- Written 2 N --
205 225 X -- Written 2 N --
206 226 X -- Written 2 N --
207 227 X -- Written 2 Y R241
208 228 X -- Written 2 N --
209 229 X -- Written 1 N --
210 230 -- Chemical Specialties Manufacturers Association Written 3 Y R173, R187, R188, R189, R190
211 231 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
212 232 X -- Written 2 Y R85
213 233 X -- Written 2 N --
214 234 X -- Written 2 N --
215 235 X -- Written 2 N --
216 236 MCS -- Written 3 N --
217 237 X -- Written 2 N --
218 238 MCS -- Written 2 Y R176
219 239 X -- Written 2 N --
220 240 MCS -- Written 2 Y R57
221 241 X -- Written 2 N --
222 242 X -- Written 2 N --
223 243 X -- Written 2 N --
17 244 X -- Written 2 N --
224 245 X -- Written 2 N --
225 246 X -- Written 2 N --
226 247 X -- Written 1 N --
227 248 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
228 249 X -- Written 2 N --
229 250 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
230 251 X -- Written 2 Y R176
17 253 X -- Written 2 N --
232 254 X -- Written 2 Y R85
233 255 X -- Written 2 N --
234 256 -- Amer. College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine Written 3 N --
19 257 MCS -- E-mail 2 Y R10, R14, R37, R59, R67, R241
235 258 HCP -- Written 2 Y R49, R178, R179, R180, R241
11 259 -- NCEHS Written 1 Y R117
6 260 MCS -- E-mail 3 Y R241
236 261 MCS -- Written 3 N --
237 262 MCS -- E-mail 2 Y R12, R42, R144, R150
238 263 MCS -- Written 3 N --
239 264 X -- Written 3 N --
15 265 MCS -- Written 2 Y R43, R134
240 266 X -- Written 2 N --
2 267 MCS -- Written 3 N --
20 268 -- ESRI E-mail 3 Y R97, R108, R114
241 269 MCS -- Written 2 N --
242 270 MCS -- Written N/A Y R125
243 271 MCS -- Written 3 Y R138, R139
244 273 X -- Written 2 N --
245 274 X -- Written 2 Y R16, R35
246 275 MCS -- Written 3 N --
247 276 X -- Written 2 N --
248 277 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
249 278 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
250 279 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
251 280 X -- Written 2 N --
252 281 X -- Written 2 N --
22 282 MCS -- Written 2 N --
253 283 MCS -- Written 2 Y R7, R101, R112, R115, R136, R140, R141
254 284 X -- Written 2 N --
255 285 MCS -- Written N/A N --
256 286 X -- Written 2 N --
257 287 X -- Written 2 N --
258 288 X -- Written 2 N --
12 289 MCS -- Written 2 Y R3, R5, R25, R36, R43, R46, R64, R103, R107, R116, R241
12 290 -- MA. Association for the Chemically Injured Written 2 Y R3, R5, R25, R36, R43, R46, R64, R103, R107, R116, R241
259 291 -- Am. Academy Clinical Toxicology Written 3 N --
260 292 MCS - Written 3 N --
261 293 HCP - Written 2 N --
262 294 MCS - Written 3 N --
263 295 HCP - Written 3 N --
4 296 HCP - Written 4 N --
264 297 MCS - E-mail 2 N --
265 298 MCS - E-mail 2 N --
266 299 MCS - Written N/A N --
267 300 X -- Written N/A N --
268 301 X -- Written 3 Y R78
21 302 -- HHS Written 3 N --
3 303 -- MCS Referral and Resources Written 2 Y R183, R184, R185, R186
269 304 MCS -- Video 3 N --
270 305 X -- Written N/A Y R12
271 306 MCS -- Written 3 Y R139
272 307 X -- Written 2 Y R81
273 308 X -- Written 4 Y R39
274 309 X -- Written 3 Y R142
275 310 -- Portland Allergy & Chemically Injured Group Written 2 N --
276 311 MCS -- Written N/A N --
277 312 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
278 313 MCS - Written 3 N --
279 314 -- Anderson Lab Written 2 Y R159, R226, R227, R228
280 315 X -- Written N/A N --
281 316 MCS - Written 3 Y R56
282 317 MCS - Written 2 Y R121, R122
283 318 MCS - Written 2 N --
284 319 MCS - Written N/A N --
285 320 MCS - Written 2 N --
286 321 MCS - Written 2 N --
25 322 X -- Written 2 Y R4, R8, R45, R80, R86, R77, R127, R241
287 323 MCS -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
288 324 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
289 325 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
290 326 MCS -- Written 3 N --
291 327 MCS -- Written N/A N --
292 328 MCS -- Written N/A N --
293 329 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
294 330 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
295 331 MCS -- Written 2 N --
296 332 MCS -- Written 1 N --
297 333 MCS -- Written N/A Y R109
298 334 HCP -- Written 3 Y R170
299 335 -- Electrical Sensitivity Network Written 3 Y R208, R209
300 336 MCS - Written 3 N --
9 337 MCS -- Written 2 N --
301 338 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
302 339 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
303 340 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
304 341 MCS -- Written 2 Y R71, R126
305 342 MCS -- Written N/A N --
306 343 -- Human Ecology Action League Written 3 Y R100, R241
307 344 MCS -- Written 3 Y R61
308 345 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
309 346 MCS -- Written N/A N --
310 347 X -- Written 2 Y R74, R113, R229, R231, R232, R239, R241
311 348 MCS -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
312 349 -- Chemical Impact Project Written N/A N --
313 350 X -- Written 2 N --
6 351 MCS - Written 3 Y R241
314 352 MCS -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
315 353 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
316 354 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
317 355 MCS -- Written 1 Y R121, R122
318 356 X -- Written 2 N --
319 357 MCS -- Written N/A N --
320 358 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
321 359 MCS -- Written N/A N --
322 360 MCS -- Written 2 Y R56, R87, R96, R126, R134, R241
323 361 MCS -- Written 2 N --
324 362 MCS -- E-mail 2 Y R121, R122, R240
325 363 -- Chemical Injury Information Network Written 2 Y R9, R140, R181, R223, R225
326 364 -- AFLCIO Written 3 N --
327 365 MCS - Written 2 Y R14, R45, R96, R123, R124, R241
328 366 HCP - Written 2 Y R63
329 367 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
1 368 MCS - E-mail N/A N --
330 369 MCS - Written N/A N --
331 370 MCS - Written 3 N --
332 371 MCS -- Written 3 N --
333 372 MCS -- Written 3 Y R45, R126, R238
334 373 X -- E-mail 3 N --
335 374 MCS -- Written 2 N --
18 375 X -- Written 2 Y R128, R129
337 377 X -- Written 2 N --
338 378 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
339 379 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
340 380 X -- Written 2 N --
341 381 X -- Written 2 N --
342 382 MCS -- Written 2 N --
343 383 -- USDA Written 3 Y R91, R120, R147, R149, R152, R160, R174, R177, R215
344 384 MCS -- Written N/A N --
345 385 X -- Written 2 N --
346 386 MCS - Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
347 387 X -- Written 2 N --
348 388 X -- Written 2 Y R176
349 389 HCP -- Written 4 N --
350 390 MCS -- Written 3 Y R55, R56, R88, R146
351 391 MCS -- Written 2 N --
352 392 -- Environmental Illness Association of Hawaii Written 1 N --
353 393 MCS -- E-mail 1 N --
354 394 MCS -- Written 3 N --
355 395 MCS -- E-mail 3 N --
356 396 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
357 397 X -- E-mail 4 Y R143, R144
358 398 X -- E-mail 3 N --
359 399 MCS -- Written 2 N --
360 400 -- Steptoe & Johnson for the American Chemical Manufacturers Association Written 2 Y Extensive List
361 401 X -- Written 2 N --
13 402 -- Environmental Health Network E-mail 2 Y R72, R78, R121, R122, R126, R144, R145
362 403 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
363 404 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
364 405 X -- Written 2 N --
365 406 X -- Written 3 Y R56
366 407 X -- E-mail N/A N --
367 408 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
368 409 X -- Written 2 N --
369 410 X -- Written 2 N --
370 411 MCS - Written N/A N --
371 412 MCS -- Written 3 N --
372 413 HCP -- Written 3 N --
1 414 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
373 415 X -- Written 2 N --
374 416 MCS -- Written N/A N --
375 417 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
376 418 MCS -- Written 2 N --
377 419 X -- Written 1 N --
378 420 MCS -- Written 4 N --
46 421 - West Coast (FL) MCS/CI Support Group Written 3 Y R176
379 422 MCS -- Written 2 Y R42, R45, R71, R157
380 423 MCS -- Written 3 Y R10, R106
381 424 X -- Written 3 N --
382 425 X -- Written 2 N --
14 426 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
383 427 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
384 428 X -- Written 2 Y R128
385 429 X -- Written 2 N --
386 430 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
387 431 MCS -- Written N/A Y R171
388 432 MCS - Written N/A N --
389 433 X -- Written 2 N --
390 435 MCS -- Written N/A N --
391 436 MCS -- Written 2 N --
392 437 X -- Written 2 N --
393 438 X -- Written 2 N --
394 439 X -- Written 2 N --
395 440 X -- Written 2 N --
396 441 X -- Written 2 N --
397 442 X -- Written 2 N --
398 443 X -- Written 2 N --
399 444 X -- Written 2 N --
400 445 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
401 446 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
14 447 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
402 448 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
403 449 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
404 450 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
405 451 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
406 452 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
407 453 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
408 454 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
409 455 X -- Written 3 N --
410 456 X -- Written 2 Y R176
411 457 X -- Written 2 N --
21 458 -- HHS Written 3 N --
412 459 X -- Written 2 N --
413 460 X -- Written 3 N --
414 461 -- USEPA Written N/A N --
415 462 X -- Written N/A N --
416 463 X -- Written 2 Y R71, R101, R112, R134, R135, R136, R137, R155
13 464 -- Environmental Health Network of CA Written 2 Y R72, R78, R121, R122, R126, R144, R145
417 465 X -- Written 2 Y R121, R122, R240
418 467 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
419 468 X -- E-mail N/A N --
420 469 X -- E-mail 3 N --
421 470 X -- E-mail N/A N --
422 471 X -- E-mail 3 N --
423 472 X -- E-mail 3 N --
424 473 X -- E-mail 3 N --
425 474 X -- E-mail 3 N --
426 475 X -- E-mail 3 N --
427 476 X -- E-mail N/A N --
428 477 MCS - E-mail 2 N --
429 478 MCS -- E-mail N/A N --
18 479 MCS -- E-mail 2 N --
18 480 MCS -- E-mail 3 N --
430 481 MCS -- Written N/A N --
431 482 X -- Written 2 N --
432 483 X -- Written 2 N --
433 484 X -- Written 2 Y R1, R2, R13, R18, R44, R56, R126, R200, R241
3 485 -- MCS Referral & Resources Written 1 Y Extensive List
1 Internal Inventory numbering system

2 Public inquiry number on comment received from CDC

3 Source: individual (X), persons with MCS (MCS), or health care professionals (HCP).

4 Medium: written, video tape (tape), or email.

5 Overall supportive nature of the comment: Supportive of the report as written (4); supportive of the report but with editorial changes (3); believes report is biased, and recommends substantive changes in report and recommendations (2); not supportive of report and recommends that no final report be written (1), and no indication of support level (N/A).

6 Comment cites additional literature (yes or no); if yes, please see attached references.

Back to Table of Contents